Review: Tears, Truth, Triumph Highlight The Miracle Season

  0 Wendy Mayer | April 09th, 2018 | High School, News

Ahead of the film’s opening, I spoke with Kathy Bresnahan, the real life coach from the movie The Miracle Season, which was based on her book of the same name and told the tale of the 2011 Iowa City West High School girls volleyball team.

In the conversation, Bresnahan, or Coach Brez as she is known to friends and players, discussed the life of Caroline “Line” Found, her memories of that roller coaster season and the path to the story making the big screen. Brez also dispelled some liberties taken in the movie.

On Monday, after seeing many positive social media posts and checking out many previews and reviews over the weekend, I was finally able to make my way to theatre to take in Line’s story.

While I don’t profess to be a renowned movie critic, I do take in more than my fair share of flicks at the local cinema and have spent a lot of time around the game of volleyball the last 16 years.

For my first watch of The Miracle Season, I took along my parents (ages 67 and 68). It is safe to say that all three of us had many teary moments during the hour and 39 minute drama, despite knowing the entire story line going in.

This movie hits each human emotion from the laughter and brevity that Line brought to life and the team to tears and heartache as tragedy ensues.

Helen Hunt embodied the hard-shell nature the producers imbued Bresnahan with, though the coach told me that she was not “three times worse than Bobby Knight” as portrayed. In between staunch coaching performances, viewers are able to see cracks of humanity in the coach, which develop as the movie goes on.

William Hurt as Ernie Found, although his story also was tweaked for the movie, was the representation of the dad everyone hopes for, one that loved his wife to the Nth degree and cherished his daughter no matter what and treated her teammates and friends as his own children. There was never a question of his emotions and the story of his journey is nearly as important as those of the players. Hurt made you want to give him a hug throughout and call your father afterward and tell him how much you loved him. He could not have been more real.

Much of the movie is told through the eyes and voice of Kelley Fliehler, Line’s best friend. You see her love and admiration for her best friend, you watch her deal with unspeakable grief and guilt, and you watch her thrust into a role on the team for which she was unprepared. Erin Moriarty, who seems like the girl next door that you have known your whole life, is totally believable in each role.

While The Miracle Season is a feel good movie of a team coming together and working toward a common goal in the face of adversity, it is not all sunshine and roses. The movie speaks to internal rumblings that can exist in the midst of trouble, the feeling of unworthiness in failure, doubt and much more.

The on-court action is often shown in choppy sequence, flashing from a serve to a dig to a slow-motion swing, but there isn’t a lot of full play by play serve to point type footage. If that is what you are looking for, this may not be your movie. The characters and their journey are front and center with the volleyball acting as a backdrop.

With that said, volleyball fans will appreciate moments of playing against “the twin towers,” the pain of a missed serve or the frustration of being on the receiving end of a stuff block. According to several media reports, many of the Moriarty’s co-stars were selected because of their volleyball skills, but the star had to attend intense training to make her skills palatable. While I didn’t find it too distracting as the focus is on the story and the individuals, volleyball purists may struggle with Moriarty’s setting skills, but, in a way, that is all part of the story.

All told, director Sean McNamara and screenwriters David Aaron Cohen and Elissa Matsueda did what they set out to do, which was share the inspirational story of Line and the West High School team. I could see this becoming the next Remember the Titans or We Are Marshall type bus trip movie that bonds teams together and fuels the fire to find success no matter the adversity.

It is a family friendly movie in terms of language and adult situations, which is part of the reason faith groups have embraced it to date. Grief and loss are a part of the story, so parents will need to gauge if their children are prepared for those life lessons.

That’s my quick take. Go see it and judge for yourself, but if you are ready for an emotional, yet uplifting few hours, it gets my vote. I could see many youth, club, high school and college teams of all sports going as a group and sharing in the themes.

Here’s a look at a few other takes from social media.

Leave a Reply


About Wendy Mayer

Wendy Mayer

Wendy Mayer has worked in athletics media relations for the last 20 years. The Northwest Missouri State alumna is currently senior writer for after spending the last 15 years with Purdue athletics.

Read More »

Don't want to miss anything?

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive our latest updates!